Athenaeus’ Deipnosophists, the most important source for ancient Greek cuisine, collects several quotations of authors whose books would be, otherwise, lost. It is thanks to Athenaeus’ work that many fragments of Archestratus’ culinary book survived.
Archestratus of Gela (or Syracuse, it is unclear, as we read in Athenaeus’ Epitome), lived in the 4th century BCE, is the author of a treatise titled Gastronomy, also called Life of Pleasure or Art of Dining, in which he explains the various foods, especially fish (at least, in the fragments quoted by Athenaeus), with particular attention to the best Mediterranean places in which one may buy it.
In addition to this information, Archestratus provides a few recipes. Generally, his plates are very simple, in contrast with the bad habit about which he complains to create excessively complex flavors that ruin the fish.
Many recipes by Archestratus just require salt and a few more ingredients, as in the case of the preparation he considers the best for grey mullet and sea bass, which must be cooked whole without removing their scales. However, he describes how Syracusans and Italiots prepare them, considering it the perfect way to ruin these delicate fishes: they season them with cheese, vinegar, and silphium.
Syracusans were famous in the Antiquity for their luxury, as reported by Athenaeus, who mentions the opinions by Aristophanes (5th century BCE) and Plato (lived between the 5th and the 4th centuries BCE), who criticizes in a letter how the Sicilians live after his first travel in Italy. They eat excessively two times every day and never sleep alone, bad habits that they practice since their youth, which prevent them from reaching temperance and wisdom.
It is unclear how the fish must be prepared since Archestratus just lists the ingredients. We used another recipe described by Archestratus in another fragment about brill, in which the author writes to pinch the skin of the fish with a knife, pour oil, and sprinkle with grated cheese. Another possibility consists in filleting the fish and season it with the other ingredients.
We used a pecorino not excessively salty, but you can try other kinds of cheese according to your taste.
Asafoetida is equivalent to the cheapest variety of silphium, called silphium Parthicum, as we read in the descriptions by Dioscorides and Theophrastus. In the classical sources, the best variety appears to be the silphium produced in Cyrene, which does no longer exist.
To know more about silphium, olive oil, cheese, and fish in the Antiquity, check out our Patreon page, in which you find articles about historical foods and translations of sources of cooking and dietetics.
To know more about foods in ancient Rome, check out our book Ancient Roman Cooking. Ingredients, Recipes, Sources (Italian edition here), available on Amazon in e-book and printed editions.
If you are interested in medieval foods, check out our new book, with the translation (into English and Italian) and a commentary of the Registrum Coquine, written in the 15th century by Johannes Bockenheim.
To support our work, you can buy us a beer or purchase our merchandise.
Gut and scale the fish, then pinch its skin with the knife. Season it with olive oil, vinegar, grated cheese, and asafoetida.
Roast it in the oven for 20 minutes. The cooking time may change depending on the size.
Serve still hot.
λάμβανε δ ̓ ἐκ Γαίσωνος ὅταν Μίλητον ἵκηαι, κεστρέα τὸν
κέφαλον καὶ τὸν θεόπαιδα λάβρακα
εἰσὶ γὰρ ἐνθάδ ̓ ἄριστοι.
[…] ὅλους δ ̓ αὐτοὺς ἀλεπίστους
ὀπτήσας μαλακῶς γλίσχρης προσένεγκε δίχ ̓ ἅλμης.
μηδὲ προσέλθῃ σοί περὶ τοὔψον τοῦτο πονοῦντι μήτε
Συρακόσιος μηδεὶς μήτ ̓ Ἰταλιώτης. οὐ γὰρ ἐπίστανται
χρηστοὺς σκευαζέμεν ἰχθῦς, ἀλλὰ διαφθείρουσι κακῶς
τυροῦντες ἅπαντα ὄξει τε ῥαίνοντες ὑγρῷ καὶ σιλφίου ἅλμῃ.
Take at Gaeson when you go to Miletus the grey mullet and the divine sea bass because in this place they are the best. They [the ones fished there] must be roasted with their scales and served moistened with brine. Do not allow a Syracusan or Italiot to approach you when you are cooking them, because they do not know how to prepare fish, but they ruin it by covering it with cheese, drowning it in vinegar with pungent silphium.
Translations of Historical Sources
De Re Coquinaria by Apicius – books 1-3
De Observatione Ciborum by Anthimus – first part (6th century)
Appendicula de Condituris Variis by Johannes Damascenus (8-9th century)
De Flore Dietarum (11th century)
Opusculum de Saporibus by Mainus de Maineris (14th century)
Anonimo Veneziano – parts 1-2 (14th century)
Registrum Coquine by Johannes von Bockenheim (15th century)
Pork Roast and Lentils with Sumac
Staitites – Ancient Greek Sweet
Columella’s Moretum and Hapalos Artos
10th-century Goat Roast
Gastris – Ancient Greek Sweet
Artolaganon Bread with Ancient Sourdough
Gustum de Praecoquis – Appetizer with Apricots
Octopus and Cucumber Salad
Copadia Agnina – Lamb Stew
Apothermum – Spelt Cakes
Pullus Parthicus – Roast Chicken
Tisana Barrica – Barley Soup
Beef Roast and Shallots
Chicken Meatballs and Mashed Peas
Sweet Fritters – Dulcia Domestica
Ancient Roman Frittata
A Saturnalia Recipe – Roast with Saffron Sauce
Muria – Ancestor of Colatura di Alici
Globi – Ancient Roman Sweet
The Diet of the Roman Legionaries – Buccellatum, Lardum, and Posca
How to make garum
Ancient Roman Gourd and Eggs
Ofella – Ancient Roman Steak
Fruit salads – Melon and Peaches
Isicia Marina – Shrimp Cakes and Cucumber Salad
Sala Cattabia – Snow and Posca
Copadia – Beef Stew
Puls Punica – Phoenician Dessert
Farcimina – Spelt and Meat Sausages
Ova Spongia ex Lacte – Sweet Omelettes
Flatbread and Chickpea Soup
Salted Fish with Arugula Sauce
Savillum – Cheesecake
Pasta and Meatballs – Minutal Terentinum
Venison Stew with Spelt Puls
Veal with Allec Sauce – Ius in Elixam Allecatum
Isicia Omentata – Meatballs Wrapped in Caul Fat
Placenta – Honey Cheesecake
Pork Laureate – Porcellum Laureatum
Poppy Seed Bread with Ancient Dry Yeast
Cured Olives and Epityrum